Exactly When Is a Hot Dog "Done?"

Improve your cooking in just 3 days

Make leftovers a thing of the past. Never burn weeknight dinner again. The Tastyble introductory cooking course will teach you to cook better than granny — and for a limited time, it's free.

By signing up, you agree to receive emails from Tastyble as described in our privacy policy.

Published February 26th, 2025, 7:27 AM EST

Dim Nikov is a culinary editor at Tastyble. He is a trained cook with food safety certification and the author of the 2022 cookbook Cooking Methods & Techniques.

For many of us, hot dogs are the ultimate convenience food. Simply rip open the package, toss them on the grill or into a pot of water, and call it a day.

And, technically, you could even eat them straight from the fridge, especially if you’re not in the at-risk groups for food poisoning. They’re pre-cooked, after all. But “edible” isn’t the same as “delicious” — or, in this case, even entirely “safe”.

The truth is, there’s a surprisingly nuanced answer to the question of when a hot dog is truly “done.” And understanding the why behind the how can take this humble food from a quick bite to a home-cooked meal that’s genuinely satisfying.

It’s About Safety, Not Just Taste

Yes, hot dogs are pre-cooked. But that doesn’t make them immune to potential bacterial growth, most notably Listeria.

This is why food safety experts — and I agree with them — recommend heating hot dogs to an internal temperature of 165°F (74°C) before eating them.

Now, let’s talk about actually enjoying your hot dog. There are two main approaches, and they yield distinct results:

Boiling Hot Dogs in Water

Moist heat is your classic, no-frills approach to cooking hot dogs.

Simply submerge the hot dogs in water, bring it to a boil, then reduce to a simmer for 4-5 minutes. A well-heated hot dog will be noticeably plumper than when it started.

The result is a plump, juicy hot dog with a consistent texture throughout. The flavor remains mild, showcasing the original taste of the frank. This is for the purists, the folks who want that quintessential ballpark dog experience.

Grilling Your Hot Dogs

This is where we introduce depth of flavor flavor to your hot dogs.

Grill or pan-fry the dogs over medium heat for 6-8 minutes, turning them occasionally to ensure even cooking. Look for that nice, even browning. Not charred, but with some color.

Dry heat triggers the Maillard reaction — that beautiful browning process that creates depth of flavor and an appealing aroma. You’ll get a slight “snap” on the exterior, while the inside stays juicy. This is for those who like a little more oomph in their hot dog.

What We Just Covered

Hot dogs might be simple, but that doesn’t mean they deserve anything less than proper cooking. Taking a few extra minutes to ensure they’re heated through — and choosing the method that suits your taste — makes all the difference.

So, ditch the “just heat ’em up” mentality. A little attention to detail can turn this everyday staple into something truly delicious and safe.

Dim Nikov — this story’s author — left his old managerial career at the turn of the decade to write about food. He is a husband, father, and trained cook certified in food safety. In 2022, he published his first cookbook, Cooking Methods & Techniques, which teaches readers how to cook instead of how to just follow recipes. More about Dim Nikov

Comments

Improve your cooking in just 3 days

Exactly When Is a Hot Dog “Done?”

It’s About Safety, Not Just Taste

Boiling Hot Dogs in Water

Grilling Your Hot Dogs

What We Just Covered

Your information — your choice

Improve your cooking in just 3 days

Exactly When Is a Hot Dog “Done?”

It’s About Safety, Not Just Taste

Boiling Hot Dogs in Water

Grilling Your Hot Dogs

What We Just Covered

Comments

Become a better cook in 3 minutes a week